Have you ever encountered a well-made film but don’t know how to handle it? This is my situation with the horror film documentary Nightmares in Red, White, and Blue: The Evolution of the American Horror Film.
This is not a bad documentary at all. The production values are solid, the interview subjects are strong choices, and the presentation of horror film history in the context of American politics, social movements, and economics is a strong one. My issue is my own knowledge of the subject.
Director Andrew Monument films Joseph Maddrey’s adaptation of his own book. The 200 page book from McFarland and Co. is condensed to a 96 minute documentary that seems to zip through space and time in its quest to be everything for everyone. By the one minute mark, we’ve already jumped from Edison’s Frankenstein in 1910 to the silent people-driven horrors of the 1920s. Just when it feels like you’re going to get into something really compelling, the film chases after the next trend.